1) Comparisons & Images Must Be Immediately Graspable
As Chekhov wrote, good writing "should be grasped at once--in a second." Some of the comparisons I've seen in your homework assignments cannot be grasped immediately. Rather, they need the filter of the intellect to puzzle them out. For example:
“I wandered around town like a crack-addicted Alzheimer’s patient with ADHD.” (We don't really know what an ADHD crackhead Alzheimer's patient looks like or does, and so our brain needs to put all of those elements together, taking us away from the story at hand.)
“I was drenched in enough sweat to fill an Ethiopian aquarium.” (How is an Ethiopian aquarium different from a normal aquarium?)
“My feelings could reach past 7,000 miles of ocean depth.” (Why 7,000 miles? And what ocean is that deep?)
2) Unconsidered Word Choices
It's very easy, especially when writing quickly, to pass over words without fully considering them. But doing this allows small errors to creep into your work. Even very successful writers do this. In class, we looked at the first page of The Da Vinci Code as an example. Here are some examples from your homework:
“The warm air surrounded the icy blue water.” (If the water were actually "surrounded," then the air would be on all sides of it, which, in the case of the sea, is impossible.)
“As sirens faded into the skyline…” (A skyline is the line in the distance where the earth meets the sky. Sounds can fade away, but they cannot fade literally into a line.)
“The blonde kid crouched over me shadowed by the sun.” (The sun, being capable only of illumination, does not shadow anything. Rather, it is something that's blocking the sun that is doing the shadowing.)
“Her skin was as pale as a sickly moon.” (There's no such thing as a sickly moon. Rather, skin as pale as the moon would appear sickly.)
HOMEWORK
Write a flash story based on one of the following prompts:
1) Make a list of the five most beautiful things and the five ugliest things you’ve ever seen. Now try to describe one of those things in the manner of “How the Water Feels to the Fishes” or “I Was Trying to Describe You to Someone.” That is, using only metaphor.
2) Write a monologue from the point of view of a terrifying authority figure (real or imagined). This person is telling you what to do, how to live your life, etc. Try to infuse your writing with terror. Remember: “show, don’t tell.”
3) Make a list of five things you’ve done that you’re ashamed of. Then pick one and write a monologue where you explain what you did and try to defend yourself. (The details can be made up. This is fiction, after all.)
4) Write a monologue inspired by the following prompt, taken from Kim Addonizio’s Ordinary Genius: “When did you first realize what it meant to be a girl or boy? I remember the moment I was made to put on a T-shirt, after spending my early years as a happy shirtless savage running wild on the Florida beaches with my brothers. Maybe the realization arrived as you observed someone else—your mother dressing up to go out, a boy on the playground beaten up for acting “feminine.” Write about that early experience.”